USA: Major League Soccer· Sports Illustrated Stadium Full time

New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC prediction

1–1
FT xG 1.65 – 1.63
Accurena prediction · missedHome 2–1Small
Best tipOver 2.562% chance · @1.57
Goals3.3 expectedOver 2.5 62% · BTTS 63%
1 · New York Red Bulls2.2240% chanceX · Draw3.7021% chance2 · New York City FC2.8639% chance
Analysis by · AccurenaLast update 20 Nov 2026, 23:59 WAT · All picks graded on the track record
Our tip · Lost ✗

Over 2.5

3 or more goals in the match · Fair chance · fair odds 1.62

62%chance1.57odds5/10rating

Why: Both teams like to attack – around 3.5 goals expected in total. New York Red Bulls won last time out. Odds of 1.57 are fair for how likely this is.

Value

2 @ 2.86 – we say 39%, the odds say 35% (+12% value)

Other bets for this game

Who wins1 ✗40% · @2.22
Win or draw12 ✗79% · @1.22
Both teams score?GG ✓63% · @1.48
GoalsOver 1.5 ✓82% · @1.18
Correct scoreCS 2–1 ✗8%

New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC prediction and tips

The match

Sunday 17 May, 00:30 WAT: New York Red Bulls welcome New York City FC to Sports Illustrated Stadium in the Major League Soccer. New York Red Bulls have 42 points in 10th place; New York City FC have 42 in 11th. Level on points apart in the table, so both teams have plenty riding on it.

Recent form

New York Red Bulls – last 5: WLLLD Last game: they beat Columbus Crew 3–2 (home). At home in that run: 2 wins, 2 defeats in 5. About 1.8 scored and 2.3 let in per game.

New York City FC – last 5: WWDLW Last game: they beat Charlotte 1–0 (away). Away from home in that run: 3 wins, 1 defeat in 4. They are scoring freely – about 2.3 goals a game.

New York City FC are in better form: 1.7 points a match lately, while the other side manage 1.2.

When they last met

Their last meeting, on 30 Apr 2026, finished New York Red Bulls 1–3 New York City FC. In the last 6 meetings New York Red Bulls won 1, New York City FC won 5 and 0 ended level, with about 3.7 goals a game (both teams scored in 4 of them).

Goals we expect

We expect New York Red Bulls to score about 1.6 and New York City FC about 1.6 – roughly 3.3 goals in all. Plenty of goals likely – 62% for 3 or more, 63% for both teams to score. Their recent games have mostly had 3 goals or more.

Other bets to consider

  • Who wins? New York Red Bulls 40%, a draw 21%, New York City FC 39%.
  • Will both teams score? We say yes – 63% at 1.48.
  • Bigger price: New York City FC to win at 2.86 – we make it 39%, the bookmaker only 35%.

Our pick (before kick-off)

Our pick before kick-off was 3 or more goals in the match – a 62% chance at odds of 1.57. Our score prediction: New York Red Bulls 2–1 New York City FC. We grade on the score after 90 minutes. A chance is not a promise – 18+ only, and only bet what you can afford to lose.

Result chances

New York Red Bulls40%fair 2.51 · @2.22
Draw21%fair 4.81 · @3.70
New York City FC39%fair 2.54 · @2.86
3.28Expected goals
1.65New York Red Bulls xG
1.63New York City FC xG
63%Both score
62%Over 2.5

Score grid: top six

1–110%
2–18%
1–28%
2–27%
1–06%
0–16%

Our goal estimate: New York Red Bulls 1.6 – 1.6 New York City FC. Even the most likely exact score is a long shot.

All markets: our price vs the bookmaker

MarketMost likelyChanceFair oddsBookmaker
Match result1 ✗40%2.512.22
Double chance12 ✗79%1.261.22
Both teams to scoreGG ✓63%1.591.48
Over/under 1.5 goalsOver 1.5 ✓82%1.221.18
Over/under 2.5 goalsOver 2.5 ✗62%1.621.57
Over/under 3.5 goalsUnder 3.5 ✓60%1.681.55
Half-time resultHT X ✗38%2.66–
Half-time / full-time1/1 ✗23%4.34–
Correct scoreCS 2–1 ✗8%12.00–

Recent results

New York Red Bulls – last 6

WLLLDW
14 Mayvs Columbus Crew3–2W
3 Mayvs FC Dallas0–2L
30 Aprvs New York City FC1–3L
26 Apr@ FC Cincinnati0–2L
23 Aprvs DC United4–4D
16 Aprvs Pittsburgh Riverhounds3–1W
1.8Scored / game
2.3Conceded / game
67%Both scored
67%Over 2.5

New York City FC – last 6

WWDLWL
14 May@ Charlotte1–0W
30 Apr@ New York Red Bulls3–1W
23 Aprvs FC Cincinnati4–4D
19 Aprvs Charlotte1–2L
15 Apr@ Westchester SC5–2W
12 Apr@ Vancouver Whitecaps0–2L
2.3Scored / game
1.8Conceded / game
67%Both scored
67%Over 2.5

Head to head

30 Apr 2026New York Red Bulls v New York City FC1–3
28 Sep 2025New York Red Bulls v New York City FC2–3
17 May 2025New York City FC v New York Red Bulls2–0
23 Nov 2024New York City FC v New York Red Bulls0–2
29 Sep 2024New York Red Bulls v New York City FC1–5
19 May 2024New York City FC v New York Red Bulls2–1
New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC head-to-head page →

Major League Soccer table

#TeamPWDLGDPts
1Nashville SC342383+4677
2Inter Miami3416126+2160
3New England Revolution3418412+858
4Chicago Fire3416711+1055
5Charlotte3415910+1554
6Philadelphia Union3414812+1450
7Columbus Crew3414515+747
8Orlando City SC3413714-1546
9FC Cincinnati34121012-846
10New York Red Bulls3412616-1442
11New York City FC34101212+442
12Toronto FC3491213-1539
13Atlanta United FC349619-1733
14DC United3471215-2233
15CF Montreal346820-3226

More Major League Soccer predictions

League hub

Frequently asked questions

What is the prediction for New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC?

We are backing Over 2.5 goals – a 62% chance at odds of 1.57.

Who will win New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC?

We give New York Red Bulls 40%, a draw 21% and New York City FC 39%.

How many goals will there be in New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC?

We expect about 3.3 goals. There is a 62% chance of 3 or more, and 63% that both teams score.

What is the predicted score for New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC?

Our score prediction is New York Red Bulls 2–1 New York City FC, with about 3.3 goals expected in total.

When is New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC?

New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC (Major League Soccer) kicks off on Sunday 17 May 2026 at 00:30 (West Africa Time) at Sports Illustrated Stadium.

All numbers come from our team ratings and goal model, with bookmakers' goal lines added for late team news. Times are in your local time. Our picks are chances, not promises – 18+, bet sensibly.