New York City FC vs New York Red Bulls prediction and tips
The match
New York City FC play New York Red Bulls in the Major League Soccer on Saturday 19 September at 00:30 WAT, at Yankee Stadium. Here is our take, in plain words. In the table, New York City FC are 11th (42 points, 34 played, in the bottom half) and New York Red Bulls are 10th (42 points, in the bottom half). Level on points apart in the table, so both teams have plenty riding on it.
Recent form
New York City FC – last 5: WLDDD Last game: they beat Real Salt Lake 2–0 (away). About 1.0 scored and 1.0 let in per game.
New York Red Bulls – last 5: WLDLD Last game: they beat Columbus Crew 1–0 (away). Away from home in that run: 1 win, 1 defeat in 3. Goals have dried up – just 0.5 a game.
When they last met
Their last meeting, on 17 May 2026, finished New York Red Bulls 1–1 New York City FC. In the last 6 meetings New York City FC won 4, New York Red Bulls won 1 and 1 ended level, with about 3.5 goals a game (both teams scored in 4 of them).
Goals we expect
We expect New York City FC to score about 2.0 and New York Red Bulls about 1.1 – roughly 3.1 goals in all. This should be lively: 3 or more goals has a 59% chance, and both teams scoring 62%. Their recent games have mostly had 2 goals or fewer.
Other bets to consider
- Who wins? New York City FC 58%, a draw 23%, New York Red Bulls 19%.
- Safer option – win or draw: New York City FC or draw – 81% at 1.25.
- Will both teams score? We say yes – 62% at 1.44.
Our pick (before kick-off)
Our pick before kick-off was New York City FC not to lose (win or draw) – a 81% chance at odds of 1.25. Our score prediction: New York City FC 2–1 New York Red Bulls. We grade on the score after 90 minutes. A chance is not a promise – 18+ only, and only bet what you can afford to lose.














