USA: US Open Cup· ScottsMiracle-Gro Field Full time

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC prediction

1–0
FT xG 2.24 – 1.39
Accurena prediction · correct ✓Home 2–1Medium
Best tipOver 1.583% chance · @1.20
Goals3.6 expectedOver 2.5 63% · BTTS 65%
1 · Columbus Crew1.8855% chanceX · Draw3.6522% chance2 · New York City FC3.5522% chance
Analysis by · AccurenaLast update 20 Nov 2026, 23:51 WAT · All picks graded on the track record
Our tip · Lost ✗

Over 1.5

2 or more goals in the match · Very likely · fair odds 1.21

83%chance1.20odds10/10rating

Why: Both teams like to attack – around 3.5 goals expected in total. Odds of 1.20 are fair for how likely this is.

Other bets for this game

Who wins1 ✓55% · @1.88
Win or draw1X ✓78% · @1.22
Both teams score?GG ✗65% · @1.55
GoalsOver 1.5 ✗83% · @1.20
Correct scoreCS 2–1 ✗9%

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC prediction and tips

The match

It is Columbus Crew against New York City FC in the US Open Cup at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field – kick-off Thursday 21 May, 00:30 WAT.

Recent form

Columbus Crew – last 5: DLLWW Last game: they drew with Philadelphia Union 1–1 (away). At home in that run: 3 wins, 1 defeat in 4. Goals are not a problem: 2.2 a game recently.

New York City FC – last 5: DWWDL Last game: they drew with New York Red Bulls 1–1 (away). Away from home in that run: 3 wins, 0 defeats in 4. They are scoring freely – about 2.5 goals a game.

Goals we expect

We expect Columbus Crew to score about 2.2 and New York City FC about 1.4 – roughly 3.6 goals in all. Plenty of goals likely – 63% for 3 or more, 65% for both teams to score. Their recent games have mostly had 3 goals or more.

Other bets to consider

  • Who wins? Columbus Crew 55%, a draw 22%, New York City FC 22%.
  • Safer option – win or draw: Columbus Crew or draw – 78% at 1.22.
  • Will both teams score? We say yes – 65% at 1.55.

Our pick (before kick-off)

Our pick before kick-off was 2 or more goals in the match – a 83% chance at odds of 1.20. Our score prediction: Columbus Crew 2–1 New York City FC. We grade on the score after 90 minutes. A chance is not a promise – 18+ only, and only bet what you can afford to lose.

Result chances

Columbus Crew55%fair 1.80 · @1.88
Draw22%fair 4.47 · @3.65
New York City FC22%fair 4.51 · @3.55
3.63Expected goals
2.24Columbus Crew xG
1.39New York City FC xG
65%Both score
63%Over 2.5

Score grid: top six

2–19%
1–18%
3–17%
2–07%
2–26%
1–06%

Our goal estimate: Columbus Crew 2.2 – 1.4 New York City FC. Even the most likely exact score is a long shot.

All markets: our price vs the bookmaker

MarketMost likelyChanceFair oddsBookmaker
Match result1 ✓55%1.801.88
Double chance1X ✓78%1.281.22
Both teams to scoreGG ✗65%1.541.55
Over/under 1.5 goalsOver 1.5 ✗83%1.211.20
Over/under 2.5 goalsOver 2.5 ✗63%1.581.65
Over/under 3.5 goalsUnder 3.5 ✓58%1.741.45
Half-time resultHT 1 ✗43%2.31–
Half-time / full-time1/1 ✗36%2.76–
Correct scoreCS 2–1 ✗9%10.81–

Recent results

Columbus Crew – last 6

DLLWWW
17 May@ Philadelphia Union1–1D
14 May@ New York Red Bulls2–3L
3 Mayvs Minnesota United FC2–3L
30 Aprvs One Knoxville4–1W
26 Aprvs Philadelphia Union2–0W
23 Aprvs Los Angeles Galaxy2–1W
2.2Scored / game
1.5Conceded / game
83%Both scored
67%Over 2.5

New York City FC – last 6

DWWDLW
17 May@ New York Red Bulls1–1D
14 May@ Charlotte1–0W
30 Apr@ New York Red Bulls3–1W
23 Aprvs FC Cincinnati4–4D
19 Aprvs Charlotte1–2L
15 Apr@ Westchester SC5–2W
2.5Scored / game
1.7Conceded / game
83%Both scored
67%Over 2.5

Head to head

No previous meetings on record between Columbus Crew and New York City FC.

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC head-to-head page →

More US Open Cup predictions

League hub

Frequently asked questions

What is the prediction for Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

We are backing Over 1.5 goals – a 83% chance at odds of 1.20.

Who will win Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

We give Columbus Crew 55%, a draw 22% and New York City FC 22%.

How many goals will there be in Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

We expect about 3.6 goals. There is a 63% chance of 3 or more, and 65% that both teams score.

What is the predicted score for Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

Our score prediction is Columbus Crew 2–1 New York City FC, with about 3.6 goals expected in total.

When is Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC (US Open Cup) kicks off on Thursday 21 May 2026 at 00:30 (West Africa Time) at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field.

All numbers come from our team ratings and goal model, with bookmakers' goal lines added for late team news. Times are in your local time. Our picks are chances, not promises – 18+, bet sensibly.