USA: US Open Cup· ScottsMiracle-Gro Field Full time

Columbus Crew vs Orlando City SC prediction

2–1
FT xG 2.24 – 1.43
Accurena prediction · correct ✓Home 2–1Medium
Best tipGG66% chance · @1.40
Goals3.7 expectedOver 2.5 71% · BTTS 66%
1 · Columbus Crew1.9156% chanceX · Draw3.6019% chance2 · Orlando City SC3.0025% chance
Analysis by · AccurenaLast update 20 Nov 2026, 22:52 WAT · All picks graded on the track record
Our tip · Won ✓

GG

Both teams score · Likely · fair odds 1.51

66%chance1.40odds6/10rating

Why: Both attacks look sharp – we expect Columbus Crew to score about 2 goals and Orlando City SC about 1.5 goals. At 1.40 the price is small on its own – it works better inside a double or an acca.

Value

1 @ 1.91 – we say 56%, the odds say 52% (+8% value)

Other bets for this game

Who wins1 ✓56% · @1.91
Win or draw12 ✓81% · @1.22
Both teams score?GG ✓66% · @1.40
GoalsOver 2.5 ✓71%
Correct scoreCS 2–1 ✓9%

Columbus Crew vs Orlando City SC prediction and tips

The match

Columbus Crew play Orlando City SC in the US Open Cup on Thursday 17 September at 00:00 WAT, at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field. Here is our take, in plain words.

Recent form

Columbus Crew – last 5: LLWLL Last game: they fell to New York Red Bulls 0–1 (home). At home in that run: 1 win, 2 defeats in 3. About 1.2 scored and 1.8 let in per game.

Orlando City SC – last 5: WWWDW Last game: they beat Toronto FC 3–0 (home). Goals are not a problem: 2.2 a game recently.

Orlando City SC are in better form: 2.2 points a match lately, while the other side manage 0.5.

When they last met

Their last meeting, on 13 Apr 2026, finished Columbus Crew 1–1 Orlando City SC.

Goals we expect

We expect Columbus Crew to score about 2.2 and Orlando City SC about 1.4 – roughly 3.7 goals in all. This should be lively: 3 or more goals has a 71% chance, and both teams scoring 66%. Their recent games have mostly had 3 goals or more.

Other bets to consider

  • Who wins? Columbus Crew 56%, a draw 19%, Orlando City SC 25%.
  • Will both teams score? We say yes – 66% at 1.40.
  • Bigger price: Columbus Crew to win at 1.91 – we make it 56%, the bookmaker only 52%.

Our pick (before kick-off)

Our pick before kick-off was Both teams score – a 66% chance at odds of 1.40. Our score prediction: Columbus Crew 2–1 Orlando City SC. We grade on the score after 90 minutes. A chance is not a promise – 18+ only, and only bet what you can afford to lose.

Result chances

Columbus Crew56%fair 1.78 · @1.91
Draw19%fair 5.31 · @3.60
Orlando City SC25%fair 4.02 · @3.00
3.67Expected goals
2.24Columbus Crew xG
1.43Orlando City SC xG
66%Both score
71%Over 2.5

Score grid: top six

2–19%
1–18%
3–17%
2–27%
2–06%
1–26%

Our goal estimate: Columbus Crew 2.2 – 1.4 Orlando City SC. Even the most likely exact score is a long shot.

All markets: our price vs the bookmaker

MarketMost likelyChanceFair oddsBookmaker
Match result1 ✓56%1.781.91 ▲
Double chance12 ✓81%1.231.22
Both teams to scoreGG ✓66%1.511.40
Over/under 1.5 goalsOver 1.5 ✓88%1.14–
Over/under 2.5 goalsOver 2.5 ✓71%1.41–
Over/under 3.5 goalsUnder 3.5 ✓50%2.00–
Half-time resultHT 1 ✗43%2.34–
Half-time / full-time1/1 ✗36%2.81–
Correct scoreCS 2–1 ✓9%10.95–

Recent results

Columbus Crew – last 6

LLWLLL
13 Sepvs New York Red Bulls0–1L
10 Sep@ DC United1–2L
6 Sepvs Colorado Rapids3–0W
30 Augvs New England Revolution1–3L
27 Aug@ Club America0–2L
23 Aug@ Nashville SC2–3L
1.2Scored / game
1.8Conceded / game
50%Both scored
67%Over 2.5

Orlando City SC – last 6

WWWDWL
13 Sepvs Toronto FC3–0W
10 Sep@ Atlanta United FC3–2W
6 Sepvs San Diego1–0W
30 Aug@ Minnesota United FC3–3D
23 Augvs Real Salt Lake2–1W
20 Augvs Chicago Fire1–2L
2.2Scored / game
1.3Conceded / game
67%Both scored
83%Over 2.5

Head to head

13 Apr 2026Columbus Crew v Orlando City SC1–1
Columbus Crew vs Orlando City SC head-to-head page →

More US Open Cup predictions

League hub

Frequently asked questions

What is the prediction for Columbus Crew vs Orlando City SC?

We are backing Both teams to score – a 66% chance at odds of 1.40.

Who will win Columbus Crew vs Orlando City SC?

We give Columbus Crew 56%, a draw 19% and Orlando City SC 25%.

How many goals will there be in Columbus Crew vs Orlando City SC?

We expect about 3.7 goals. There is a 71% chance of 3 or more, and 66% that both teams score.

What is the predicted score for Columbus Crew vs Orlando City SC?

Our score prediction is Columbus Crew 2–1 Orlando City SC, with about 3.7 goals expected in total.

When is Columbus Crew vs Orlando City SC?

Columbus Crew vs Orlando City SC (US Open Cup) kicks off on Thursday 17 September 2026 at 00:00 (West Africa Time) at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field.

All numbers come from our team ratings and goal model, with bookmakers' goal lines added for late team news. Times are in your local time. Our picks are chances, not promises – 18+, bet sensibly.